Start with a key count
Before you worry about where spare keys should live, find out how many you have. Go through this list and note every key, including the ones you have not touched in years.
- Front and back door: your own keys and every spare
- Garage door, side gate, shed padlock
- Window locks (often small, identical, and kept "somewhere in the kitchen")
- Mailbox or letterbox
- Bike locks, including the spare that came in the box
- Car spares and fobs (see where to keep car keys)
- Filing cabinet, desk drawer, the small safe
- Keys you hold for other people: a neighbor's house key, a parent's place, a friend's apartment while they are away
- Copies you have given out: the dog walker, the cleaner, a relative, the neighbor who waters plants
- The mystery keys on a ring in the junk drawer that nobody can identify
The last item is worth an afternoon. Try each mystery key in the locks you have. Anything that fits nothing can usually go; anything that fits gets a home.
The part people forget: who has a copy
Finding a spare is one problem. Remembering that the dog walker still has one, two years after the dog walking stopped, is another. A simple register answers both. It does not need to be fancy. It needs to answer three questions for each key: what does it open, where is it, and who else has one.
| Key | Where it lives | Copies held by |
|---|---|---|
| Front door spare | Blue tin, top kitchen cupboard | Mom; Sam next door |
| Shed padlock | Hook inside the garage door | Nobody else |
| Window keys (x2) | Cutlery drawer, back left | Nobody else |
| Neighbor's key (Sam) | Hall drawer, red key ring | We hold it |
| Back door copy | Dog walker (Jess) | Ask back when the contract ends |
Notice what the register does not contain: an address, a lockbox code, or an alarm code. More on that below.
When you have lost your keys again
The moment usually goes like this: you are at the door, coat on, and your keys are not in the bowl. Before you start a full search, run through these in order.
- Check the last three surfaces you put something down on. Kitchen counter, the bag you carried in, the pocket of yesterday's coat.
- Use the spare and leave. This is what the spare is for. If you know exactly where it lives, you are out the door in a minute and can look properly later.
- Note that the spare is now in use. The most common way to end up with no spare at all is to grab it in a hurry, then lose it too. When the main set turns up, put the spare back in its spot that day.
- If they are really gone, decide about the locks. Keys lost somewhere public with something identifying attached are a different risk from keys lost inside the house. If in doubt, talk to a locksmith.
If you lose keys often, our guide to where to keep spare keys covers the physical side: which places work for a spare and which ones burglars check first.
Security rules worth keeping
Never label a key with your address, and never put your name and street on a key ring. A lost key with no address is a nuisance; a lost key with one is an invitation. Label by purpose instead: "back door," "shed," a colored cap.
Do not jot alarm codes, lockbox codes or safe combinations anywhere: not on a tag, not in a notes app, not in Jot the Spot. Keep those in a password manager. Your key register should say where a key is, never how to get past the lock without one.
It also helps to keep the list of people holding copies short and current. When someone moves out, a contractor finishes, or a relationship ends, ask for the key back and update the register the same day.
Keeping the register by voice
A register on paper works until the day a spare moves and nobody updates it. Jot the Spot keeps it as a side effect of saying things as they happen. When you hand a copy to the dog walker you say, "Back door spare, given to Jess the dog walker." When she returns it: "Back door spare, blue tin, top kitchen cupboard." Ask "where's the back door spare?" and you get the newest answer, with the history of where it has been and who jotted each move.
You can also ask by place. "What's in the hall drawer?" lists every key you have jotted there, which is handy when you are holding three unlabeled keys and trying to work out which is the neighbor's.
With household sharing, whoever moves a key can say so, and everyone else's answer updates. On iPhone you can ask through Siri with your hands full of shopping.
The limit: it only knows what you tell it. It is not a key tracker. If a spare moves silently, the app points at the old spot until someone jots the new one. For a tracker that rings from a key ring, compare Jot the Spot with AirTag and Tile; many people use both.
Questions people ask
How many spare house keys should I have?
One spare kept at home and one with someone you trust nearby covers most situations. More copies mean more to keep track of, so make each one count.
Is it safe to put my spare keys on a labeled key ring?
Label what the key opens ("back door," "shed"), never your name or address. A key with an address on it is much riskier if it is lost.
Should I store my alarm code in Jot the Spot?
No. Do not jot alarm, lockbox or safe codes anywhere. Keep them in a password manager and use Jot the Spot only for where physical things are.
Can Jot the Spot find keys I lost?
Only if you jotted where you put them. It is a memory, not a tracker, so it cannot locate keys you never told it about.