Item guide

Where to keep spare keys

A spare key has two jobs: be easy for you to reach and hard for anyone else to find. Most hiding spots manage only one.

Updated October 10, 2026 · 4 min read

Where to keep spare keys is really two questions. Outside the house: where can a key wait for the day you lock yourself out? Inside the house: where do the extra keys for the back door, the shed, the bike lock and the neighbor's place live so you can find them? This page covers both. If your problem is tracking who has a copy of which key, see managing spare keys and copies.

Mistakes to avoid first

  1. Under the doormat. It is the first place anyone looks, including people you would rather did not.
  2. The fake rock. They are sold in garden centers everywhere, and they tend to look like the only rock of that shape near the door.
  3. Above the door frame or in the porch light. Same problem: easy to guess, and in plain sight of the street.
  4. In the plant pot by the door. Easy to see someone retrieving it, and easy to lose in the soil.
  5. A tag with your address. A lost key with your address on it is an invitation. Never put an address or a house number on a key.
  6. A loose key in a drawer with ten others. Inside the house, the problem flips: the key is safe but unidentifiable.

Better places for the outside spare

OptionWhy it worksTrade-off
A trusted neighborNothing outside the house to find; someone nearby can also let in a plumberThey need to be home, and you need to remember which neighbor has it after a few years
A combination key safe (lockbox)Works at 3 a.m.; you can share the code with a dog walker and change it laterVisible to passers-by. Mount it somewhere discreet, use a good-quality model, and check your home insurance terms.
A nearby friend or family memberVery low riskLess useful if they live across town
Your workplace desk or lockerEasy to reach on a weekdayUseless at the weekend or when you change jobs
A smart lock or keypadNo physical spare to hide at allCost, batteries, and you still want a key somewhere for when it fails

Inside the house: one home for every extra key

The keys people lose most are not the outside spare. They are the ones used twice a year: the window locks, the gas meter box, the garage side door, the camper, the old padlock. Give them a single home.

  • A key cabinet or a row of hooks inside a closet door, not by the front door where they are visible through glass.
  • A small labeled box in a kitchen or utility drawer, if you prefer them out of sight.
  • Colored key caps or tags so you can tell similar keys apart at a glance.

Labeling keys without giving anything away

A label should tell you what a key opens without telling a stranger. Some ways that work:

  • Use names only you understand: "Back" for the back door, "Gran" for a relative's house, "Blue" for the bike lock.
  • Use color codes and keep the key to the code inside the house.
  • Number the tags and keep a list of what each number opens somewhere separate.
  • Never write an address, a street name or a car registration on a tag.

Where to look when the spare is gone

  1. The last coat or bag you used when you needed it.
  2. The ignition or door of whatever it opens, if it is a car, shed or bike lock.
  3. The neighbor or friend who might have borrowed it and kept it.
  4. Next to the main set: spares often end up threaded onto your everyday keyring.
  5. The junk drawer, which is where loose keys drift. See our junk drawer guide for taming it.

If a spare for an outside door is truly lost, and it could be linked to your home, consider changing or rekeying the lock.

Remembering which spot you chose

The best hiding place is no use if you cannot recall it eighteen months later. That is the gap Jot the Spot fills. You tap the mic and say: "Spare front door key, Maria at number 12 has it." Or "Shed key, hook inside the coat closet, yellow tag." When you are locked out, you ask "who has the spare front door key?" and get your own words back. The question works offline, which helps when you are standing on the doorstep with a flat phone signal.

When the key moves, jot it again; the app keeps the history, so you can also see where it was before. If you live with others, household sharing means anyone at home can ask. It does not track keys, though: if a key gets moved without a jot, the app still names the old spot. For a key that wanders, a Bluetooth tag may suit better; our comparison with AirTag and Tile explains the difference.

Questions people ask

Is a key lockbox safe?

A good-quality combination lockbox mounted somewhere discreet is far better than a key under the mat. Change the code after sharing it, and check your home insurance terms, since some policies have conditions about key safes.

Should I put my name or address on my keys?

No. If the keys are lost, an address tells a finder exactly which door they open. Use initials, colors or a code only you know.

How many spare house keys should I have?

Most households do well with one outside spare (with a neighbor or in a key safe) and one inside. More copies mean more places to lose track of.

Give your home a memory.

Start free with 10 things. Say where it went once, ask for it whenever you need it.

Free for 10 things · Unlimited from $1.67/mo billed yearly · Pricing