The short verdict
These are not really rivals. Apple AirTag and Tile are Bluetooth trackers: small tags you attach to things that move, so your phone can show you where they are. Jot the Spot is not a tracker at all. It is an app to remember where you put things, by voice. Use a tracker for the few things that leave the house with you. Use a memory app for the hundreds of things that sit still in drawers, boxes and lofts. Most people who lose things often are best served by both.
A quick test: does it move, or does it sit?
Go through the things you have lost in the last year and sort them with this table.
| The thing | Better fit | Why |
|---|---|---|
| House keys, car keys | Tracker | They move every day and are easy to attach a tag to |
| Backpack, handbag, suitcase | Tracker | Travels, can be left behind or misrouted |
| Wallet | Tracker (card-style tag or one tucked inside) | Moves with you; costly to lose |
| Passport, birth certificates | Memory app | Sits in one place for months; nobody wants a tag stuck to a passport |
| Box of holiday decorations | Memory app | Lives in the attic or loft eleven months a year |
| Drill bits, spare fuses, the allen key for the bed | Memory app | Too small or too many to tag |
| Warranties, receipts, the boiler manual | Memory app | Paper; you need the folder, not a tag |
| Spare medication, sunscreen | Memory app | Has an expiry date worth remembering too |
For most homes, the tracker column has three to six items. The memory column goes on for pages.
What the trackers actually offer (as of October 2026)
Apple AirTag
- Price: $29 for one, $99 for a 4-pack on Apple's store.
- Battery: a user-replaceable CR2032 coin cell that Apple says lasts more than a year, and your iPhone tells you when to swap it.
- Finding: uses Apple's Find My network, where nearby Apple devices relay its location anonymously. Precision Finding gives on-screen directions on recent iPhones (Apple lists iPhone Air and iPhone 15 or later, with some exceptions).
- Needs: an Apple Account and an iPhone or iPad on iOS or iPadOS 26 or later. It is rated IP67 for water resistance.
Source: apple.com/airtag.
Tile
- Who runs it: Tile is part of Life360; tile.com now redirects to Life360's Tile pages.
- Phones: works with the Life360 app on both iPhone and Android.
- Models: Tile Mate lists a 350 ft range and a built-in 3-year battery that is not replaceable. Tile Pro lists up to 500 ft and a replaceable CR2032 coin cell good for about a year.
- Price: Life360 lists the Tile Pro at $34.99 and a Mate plus Sticker 2-pack at $44.99.
- Extras: Mate and Sticker include an SOS button that alerts your Life360 Circle.
Side by side
| Jot the Spot | AirTag / Tile | |
|---|---|---|
| What it does | Remembers where you said you put something | Shows where a tagged object is |
| Works for things that move on their own (or get moved) | No, only as fresh as your last jot | Yes, that is the point |
| Works for papers, tiny parts, boxes | Yes, anything you can name | Only if you can attach a tag |
| Hardware | None | One tag per item |
| Cost for 50 things | $19.99 a year on Unlimited (10 things free) | One tag each, roughly $22 to $35 a tag at the list prices above |
| Batteries | None | Coin cell to replace, or a sealed battery when the tag wears out |
| Phones | iPhone and Android | AirTag: iPhone or iPad. Tile: iPhone and Android |
| Works with no signal | Yes, answers come from your phone | Close-range finding uses Bluetooth; remote location depends on the network |
When a tracker is the better choice
- Things that leave the house. If you leave a bag on a train, no memory app helps. A tracker might.
- Things other people move without telling you. A teenager borrows the car keys. A tracker still knows where they went. Jot the Spot would still point at the hook.
- Checked luggage. A tag in a suitcase can show you where it ended up.
- Pets' collars and kids' bags. Follow the manufacturer's guidance on what tags are designed for, but things that wander need a signal, not a note.
When a memory app is the better choice
Anything that sits still for a long time, anything you cannot tag, and anything there are lots of. Jot it in one sentence when you put it away: "Christmas lights, green crate, left side of the loft." Months later, ask "where are the Christmas lights?" and you get the spot, the area and, on Unlimited, a photo of the spot if you took one. Our guide to storing holiday decorations covers the putting-away half.
It also helps with the one thing trackers cannot do for documents: knowing where you filed something "somewhere safe". See where to keep your passport for a good home for travel papers.
Using both together
- Tag the few things that travel: keys, wallet, everyday bag, suitcase.
- Jot everything that gets put away: documents, spares, seasonal stuff, tools.
- Jot where the spare tags and coin cells are. "Spare CR2032 batteries, junk drawer, kitchen." It is surprisingly easy to lose those too.
- When a tagged thing goes into long-term storage, jot it as well. The tag's battery may be flat by the time you need it again.
Tracker prices and specs as of October 2026, from Apple and Life360. Prices and models change; check the official pages before you buy.
Questions people ask
Can I put an AirTag on my passport?
You could keep one in a passport wallet, but for a document that sits in a drawer most of the year, remembering the drawer is usually enough. A tag earns its keep on things that travel.
Does AirTag work with Android phones?
Setting up and finding an AirTag needs an iPhone or iPad. Apple says Android phones can receive alerts if an unknown AirTag is travelling with them. Tile works with both iPhone and Android through the Life360 app.
Does Jot the Spot use Bluetooth to find things?
No. It is a memory app: you say where you put something and ask later. It does not track location, so it pairs well with a tracker rather than replacing one.
How often do tracker batteries need changing?
Apple says an AirTag battery lasts more than a year. Life360 lists about a year for the Tile Pro coin cell and three years for the sealed Tile Mate battery, after which the tag is replaced.